10 Best Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis
The ten best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis include Iozzo’s Garden of Italy, Tony’s of Indianapolis, Vicino, Nesso Italian Kitchen, Rosemary and Olive, Maialina, Mama Carolla’s, Iaria’s Italian Restaurant, Sangiovese Ristorante, and OP Italian. The Italian food culture in Indianapolis, Indiana is distinguished by its deep family legacies and unique, historic restaurant locations. Fine dining is exemplified by the luxurious steakhouse and Italian concept of Tony's of Indianapolis, while historic specialists such as Iaria's Italian Restaurant provide a genuine taste of classic Italian-American cooking that dates back nearly a century.
The hubs for Italian cuisine are found in neighborhoods like Downtown, SoBro, and Fountain Square. The Italian restaurants in Indianapolis consist of historic family-owned establishments, sophisticated regional kitchens, and modern rustic eateries. These restaurants offer a spectrum of atmospheres, from the romantic, old-world dining rooms inside the historic villa of Mama Carolla’s to the elegant, grand spaces of downtown fine-dining destinations. This blend of enduring neighborhood fixtures and refined modern restaurants is a defining characteristic of the city's food culture, which is celebrated each year during the popular Holy Rosary Italian Street Festival.
The city's Italian establishments are recognized for their role in both traditional and contemporary dining. Iozzo's Garden of Italy stands out as the definitive overall experience, celebrated for its historic family recipes, excellent house-made pasta, and beautiful garden patio. The distinction for a premier fine-dining experience among Indianapolis Italian restaurants goes to Tony’s of Indianapolis, which provides a sophisticated meal with impeccable service. For a unique and romantic meal, Mama Carolla’s is a local favorite, known for its classic comfort food served within a 1920s villa. Establishments such as Nesso and Iozzo's provide menu options for both vegan and Gluten-Free diets.
10 Best Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis are listed below.
-
1
Iozzo's Garden of ItalyIozzo’s Garden of Italy is a fine-dining restaurant that continues a family legacy dating back to the 1930s. The restaurant serves classic and contemporary Italian dishes in a historic building near downtown Indianapolis. The interior is elegant, and the restaurant is known for its large, secluded outdoor garden patio.- Item Prices 70
- Average Item Price $15.91
Type of Restaurant:Fine Dining
Type of Food:Italian
Signature Dishes:Lasagna BologneseIozzo's Signature MeatballsVeal Saltimbocca
Location:946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Special Feature:The restaurant features a prominent, beautifully landscaped garden patio with fountains and string lights, offering a distinct outdoor dining experience.
What Makes It Special:Iozzo's is celebrated for its deep family history in the Indianapolis restaurant scene and its blend of traditional recipes with modern culinary execution.
What Sets It Apart:The combination of its historic family narrative with its sophisticated atmosphere and sought-after garden patio creates a unique and memorable fine-dining destination.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMFriday: 11:00 AM – 3:30 PM, 4:00 PM – 10:00 PMSaturday: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PMSunday: 4:00 PM – 8:00 PM
Price:$30 to $50 per person
-
2
Vicino Ristorante ItalianoVicino is a neighborhood Italian restaurant that serves a menu of rustic, regional dishes in a relaxed and intimate setting. The restaurant focuses on simple preparations that highlight fresh, high-quality ingredients. The name "Vicino" means "neighbor" in Italian, reflecting its community-focused identity.- Item Prices 100
- Average Item Price $10.80
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Regional Italian
Signature Dishes:Cacio e PepeTagliatelle alla BolognesePollo al Mattone
Location:350 Massachusetts Avenue, Suite 150, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Special Feature:The restaurant has an open kitchen that allows diners to see the chefs at work, creating a dynamic and engaging atmosphere.
What Makes It Special:Vicino is celebrated for its authentic, straightforward Italian cooking and its cozy, welcoming ambiance on the bustling Massachusetts Avenue.
What Sets It Apart:Its commitment to simple, authentic regional Italian food, rather than Italian-American fare, distinguishes it as a go-to spot for a true taste of Italy.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday, Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Price:$30 to $50 per person
-
3
Maialina Italian Kitchen and BarMaialina Italian Kitchen + Bar is a contemporary restaurant in the Fountain Square neighborhood that serves rustic Italian cuisine. The menu features house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and a selection of shareable plates. The restaurant has a stylish, industrial-chic interior with a lively bar.- Item Prices 14
- Average Item Price $10.86
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Modern Italian, Pizza
Signature Dishes:Cacio e PepeMaialina Pizza (Sausage and mushroom)Meatballs
Location:1103 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Special Feature:The restaurant has a large, dog-friendly outdoor patio that is a popular spot in the vibrant Fountain Square cultural district.
What Makes It Special:Maialina is known for its energetic atmosphere and its modern, well-executed take on Italian classics, making it a social hub in its neighborhood.
What Sets It Apart:Its trendy location, combined with a menu that successfully balances both high-quality pasta and wood-fired pizza, makes it a versatile and popular dining destination.
Operating Hours:Sunday, Tuesday – Thursday: 5:00 PM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PMMonday: Closed
Price:$20 to $30 per person
-
4
Mama Carolla'sMama Carolla’s is a long-standing Italian restaurant located in a historic 1920s Mediterranean-style villa in the SoBro neighborhood. The restaurant serves traditional Italian-American fare in a series of intimate, cozy dining rooms. The atmosphere is romantic and nostalgic.- Item Prices 58
- Average Item Price $13.80
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian-American
Signature Dishes:Rosemary Chicken LasagnaVeal ParmesanSpaghetti and Meatballs
Location:1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Special Feature:The restaurant's unique setting inside a historic villa, complete with a garden patio and multiple distinct dining rooms, provides a one-of-a-kind ambiance.
What Makes It Special:Mama Carolla's is celebrated for its romantic, old-world atmosphere and its consistent delivery of classic Italian-American comfort food for over two decades.
What Sets It Apart:Its unique location in a historic residential house is its most defining feature, creating a transportive and memorable dining experience unlike any other in the city.
Operating Hours:Tuesday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 9:30 PMSunday – Monday: Closed
Price:$20 to $30 per person
-
5
Iaria's Italian RestaurantIaria’s Italian Restaurant is one of Indianapolis's oldest and most historic Italian establishments, family-owned and operated since 1933. Located near downtown, the restaurant serves classic Italian-American red-sauce dishes in a traditional, no-frills setting. The atmosphere is deeply nostalgic and rooted in history.- Item Prices 67
- Average Item Price $10.17
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian-American
Signature Dishes:LasagnaSpaghetti with Meat SauceItalian Fried Chicken
Location:317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Special Feature:The restaurant's interior is filled with historic photos and memorabilia, showcasing its nearly century-long history in the city.
What Makes It Special:Iaria's is known for its history and its role as a foundational piece of Indianapolis's Italian-American community, offering a true taste of the past.
What Sets It Apart:Its status as a multi-generational, historic institution, serving the same classic recipes for decades, makes it a unique and enduring landmark in the city's dining scene.
Operating Hours:Tuesday – Thursday: 4:30 PM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 4:30 PM – 9:45 PMSunday – Monday: Closed
Price:$20 to $30 per person
-
6
Sangiovese RistoranteSangiovese Ristorante is an established Italian restaurant with a focus on providing a classic, upscale-casual dining experience. The menu features a broad range of traditional Italian dishes, from pastas to veal and seafood. The restaurant has a warm, clubby atmosphere with dark wood and a prominent bar.- Item Prices 83
- Average Item Price $20.12
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian
Signature Dishes:Veal PiccataTortellini alla PannaCioppino
Location:2727 E 86th St Suite 110, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Special Feature:The restaurant has a loyal, long-standing clientele, making it a reliable and consistent fixture for its north-side neighborhood.
What Makes It Special:Sangiovese is known for its consistent quality and traditional service, offering a classic Italian restaurant experience that has endured for decades.
What Sets It Apart:Its specific role as a dependable, old-school neighborhood anchor on the north side distinguishes it from the newer, trendier restaurants in downtown and other cultural districts.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday: 5:00 PM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 9:30 PMSunday: 5:00 PM – 8:30 PM
Price:$30 to $60 per person
-
7
Tony’s of IndianapolisTony’s of Indianapolis is an upscale steakhouse and Italian restaurant located in the downtown area. The restaurant offers a luxurious dining experience with a menu that combines prime steaks, fresh seafood, and classic Italian specialties. The modern, sophisticated dining room features high ceilings and large windows.Type of Restaurant:Fine Dining
Type of Food:Italian, Steakhouse
Signature Dishes:Filet MignonSea BassHouse Made Ravioli
Location:110 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Special Feature:The restaurant is situated directly across from the Indiana State Capitol, offering impressive views of the government buildings and downtown skyline.
What Makes It Special:Tony's is known for its impeccable, high-touch service and its consistent execution of both steakhouse and Italian classics in a grand, formal setting.
What Sets It Apart:Its dual identity as a premier steakhouse and a high-end Italian restaurant, combined with its prime downtown location, makes it a top destination for business dinners and special occasions.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday, Sunday: 5:00 PM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Price:Over $100 per person
-
8
Nesso Italian KitchenNesso Italian Kitchen is a modern Italian restaurant located in The Alexander hotel. The menu offers a contemporary interpretation of Italian cuisine with a focus on house-made pastas and seasonal ingredients. The dining room is stylish and sophisticated, with a sleek design and an energetic bar area.Type of Restaurant:Fine Dining
Type of Food:Modern Italian
Signature Dishes:AgnolottiGnocchiBranzino
Location:339 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Special Feature:The restaurant offers a popular "Porron and Pasta" night, featuring a communal Spanish wine pitcher and a selection of pastas.
What Makes It Special:Nesso is known for its inventive, chef-driven menu that puts a creative spin on Italian classics, served in a chic, modern hotel setting.
What Sets It Apart:Its location within a contemporary art hotel and its focus on a modern, experiential approach to dining distinguish it from the city's more traditional Italian establishments.
Operating Hours:Monday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PMSunday: 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Price:$50 to $100 per person
-
9
Rosemary and OliveRosemary and Olive is a family-owned Italian restaurant that serves a menu of traditional, homestyle recipes. The atmosphere is casual and unpretentious, designed to feel like a welcoming neighborhood eatery. The restaurant emphasizes from-scratch cooking for all its dishes.Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian
Signature Dishes:LasagnaChicken ParmesanFettuccine Alfredo
Location:870 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Special Feature:The restaurant operates in a small, intimate space, creating a personal and cozy dining experience for its guests.
What Makes It Special:Rosemary and Olive is known for its authentic, family-recipe Italian comfort food served in a friendly and straightforward setting.
What Sets It Apart:Its specific focus on being a small, family-run, neighborhood-oriented restaurant provides a more personal and less commercial alternative to larger establishments.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 11:00 PMSunday: 5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Price:$30 to $50 per person
-
10
OP ItalianOP Italian is a modern Italian restaurant located in the JW Marriott hotel in downtown Indianapolis. The restaurant serves an approachable menu of classic Italian-American dishes, including brick-oven pizzas, pastas, and steaks. The large, contemporary space is designed to accommodate hotel guests and convention-goers.Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian-American, Pizza
Signature Dishes:Fettuccine AlfredoMargherita PizzaThe "OP" Calzone
.jpeg.jpeg)
Location:10 S West St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Special Feature:The restaurant's prime location within one of the city's largest convention hotels makes it a convenient and accessible option for visitors to downtown.
What Makes It Special:OP Italian is known for its reliable execution of familiar Italian-American favorites in a modern, high-traffic hotel environment.
What Sets It Apart:Its specific function as a large-scale hotel restaurant, designed to serve a high volume of diverse guests with an accessible menu, distinguishes it from smaller, independent establishments.
Operating Hours:Permanently Closed
Price:$50 to $100 per person
What Makes Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis Famous?
Italian restaurants in Indianapolis are famous for their deep multi-generational family histories. The city's Italian dining heritage was built by families who opened establishments like Iaria’s Italian Restaurant in 1933, creating a strong foundation for traditional red-sauce Italian-American cooking. The best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis are often those that blend this rich history with modern fine dining, such as Iozzo's Garden of Italy. The Italian food Indianapolis is known for is also found in unique settings, like the historic 1920s villa that houses Mama Carolla’s, making the restaurants themselves as memorable as the food.
What Type of Italian Restaurant is Commonly Found in Indianapolis?
Indianapolis contains a mix of historic Italian-American establishments, modern regional kitchens, and upscale dining rooms. This variety reflects the city's appreciation for both long-standing tradition and contemporary culinary trends. The list below details the common types.
- Historic Italian-American Restaurants: These are multi-generational, family-owned establishments that have been operating for decades. Iaria’s Italian Restaurant and Mama Carolla’s are prime examples, serving classic comfort food in nostalgic settings.
- Modern & Regional Italian: These restaurants focus on contemporary interpretations of Italian food, house-made pastas, and specific regional dishes. Nesso Italian Kitchen, Vicino, and Maialina fit this category, operating in trendy, energetic environments.
- Upscale Italian & Steakhouses: These are fine-dining destinations that offer sophisticated service and high-end menus. Iozzo’s Garden of Italy provides a classic, elegant experience, while Tony’s of Indianapolis combines a premier steakhouse with Italian specialties.
- Neighborhood Family Restaurants: These are smaller, casual spots that serve as reliable local go-tos. Rosemary and Olive is an example of this type, offering homestyle recipes in an intimate, family-run setting.
Does Indianapolis Have an Authentic Italian Restaurant?
Yes, Indianapolis has authentic Italian restaurants, such as Vicino and Nesso Italian Kitchen. Authenticity at these establishments is demonstrated by their focus on specific regional recipes and high-quality ingredients. Vicino, which means "neighbor," serves rustic, simple dishes like Cacio e Pepe and Tagliatelle alla Bolognese that adhere to true Italian preparation methods, rather than Americanized versions. Nesso Italian Kitchen showcases authenticity through its chef-driven, modern approach, crafting precise house-made pastas like Agnolotti and featuring dishes that respect the integrity of seasonal Italian ingredients.
What are the Signature Dishes of the Best Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis?
The best Italian restaurants in Indianapolis are known for signature dishes like the Rosemary Chicken Lasagna, classic Lasagna Bolognese, and authentic Cacio e Pepe. These dishes represent the city's blend of historic comfort food and modern culinary craft. The most notable signature dishes are listed below.
- Rosemary Chicken Lasagna: A unique and famous specialty from Mama Carolla’s, this dish layers pasta with chicken, spinach, and a creamy rosemary sauce.
- Lasagna Bolognese: A benchmark of the city's traditional Italian-American restaurants, this classic meat lasagna is a signature item at both Iozzo's Garden of Italy and Iaria's Italian Restaurant.
- Iozzo's Signature Meatballs: A well-known appetizer from Iozzo's Garden of Italy, these meatballs are made from a historic family recipe and served with marinara and ricotta.
- Cacio e Pepe: A simple yet difficult-to-master Roman pasta dish that has become a staple at modern restaurants like Vicino and Maialina, showcasing their dedication to authentic technique.
- Veal Saltimbocca: A classic fine-dining entree from Iozzo's Garden of Italy, featuring veal scaloppine with prosciutto, sage, and a white wine sauce.
Does Indianapolis Enjoy Italian Food?
Yes, Indianapolis enjoys Italian food. This is proven by the remarkable longevity of historic, family-owned establishments like Iaria’s Italian Restaurant, which has been a city staple since 1933. The cuisine's popularity is also demonstrated by the success of both traditional restaurants in residential neighborhoods, such as Mama Carolla’s, and modern, chef-driven kitchens in bustling downtown districts, like Nesso and Vicino. Italian food serves as a cornerstone of the city’s dining culture, acting as a go-to choice for everything from casual family dinners to celebratory fine-dining experiences.
Are There Vegan Options in Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis?
Yes, several Italian restaurants in Indianapolis have vegan options, such as Nesso Italian Kitchen, Maialina, and Vicino. These establishments accommodate plant-based diets. Modern restaurants like Nesso Italian Kitchen and Vicino can create vegan dishes using seasonal vegetables and house-made pasta with simple sauces like marinara or aglio e olio. Maialina can prepare its wood-fired pizzas without cheese and offers a selection of vegetable-based small plates that are suitable for vegan diners.
Do Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis Offer Gluten-Free Options?
Yes, Italian restaurants in Indianapolis offer Gluten-Free options, including Iozzo’s Garden of Italy, Tony’s of Indianapolis, and Nesso Italian Kitchen. These restaurants provide choices for diners with gluten sensitivities. Fine-dining establishments like Iozzo’s and Nesso offer Gluten-Free pasta substitutes for many of their signature dishes. Tony’s of Indianapolis, as a premier steakhouse, features a menu with numerous naturally Gluten-Free entrees, including prime steaks and fresh seafood, ensuring safe and high-quality choices for guests.
What is the Average Meal Price for Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis?
Italian restaurant meal prices in Indianapolis start at $20 for a casual dinner and can exceed $100 for a fine-dining experience. A person can expect to pay between $20 and $40 at budget-friendly, historic spots like Iaria’s Italian Restaurant or Rosemary and Olive. Mid-range establishments such as Mama Carolla’s or Maialina cost between $30 and $60 per person for an entree and a drink. For a high-end meal, restaurants like Iozzo’s Garden of Italy or Nesso start at $50, while a multi-course dinner at a premier destination like Tony’s of Indianapolis will cost over $100 per person.
Find your next favorite spot
Can't decide? start here: