Home
10 Best Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis

10 Best Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis

The ten best casual restaurants in Indianapolis include Livery, Conner's Kitchen and Bar, Rosemary and Olive, Yard House, Culinary Dropout, Union 50, The Rathskeller, Bakersfield, Agave & Rye, and Diavola. Casual dining in Indianapolis, Indiana is defined by its many restaurants housed in repurposed historic buildings. Livery serves Latin food in a 19th-century stable, Union 50 operates in a former union hall, and The Rathskeller is a century-old German restaurant in the historic Athenaeum building.

Indianapolis's casual dining spots are found in revitalized downtown neighborhoods like Mass Ave and Fletcher Place, often in unique architectural settings. The lineup of restaurants features high-energy gastropubs with live music, historic German beer gardens, and modern taquerias. The price for a meal at a casual restaurant in Indianapolis is between $20 and $70 per person.

Livery stands out as a top choice for its unique setting in a renovated horse stable, its creative Latin American small plates, and its popular rooftop patio. Bakersfield serves some of the best food in the city with its authentic, high-quality street tacos. Union 50 offers a more refined, chef-driven dinner experience with live music. Agave & Rye provides vegan taco options, while Livery has many gluten-free dishes, including its paella and grilled steak.

The top casual restaurants in Indianapolis are listed below.

10 Best Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis are listed below.

1 Conner's Kitchen + Bar
2 Yard House
3 Culinary Dropout
4 The Rathskeller
5 Bakersfield
6 Agave & Rye
7 Diavola Pizza
8 Livery
9 Rosemary and Olive
10 Union 50

What Makes Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis Famous?

Casual restaurants in Indianapolis, Indiana, are famous for their locations within repurposed historic buildings and their strong connection to live music and entertainment. The city's industrial past provides a unique backdrop, with popular dining spots housed in former union halls (Union 50), horse stables (Livery), and automobile factories (The Stutz). This architectural reuse is a defining feature of the dining experience. Additionally, Indianapolis is known for its many high-energy gastropubs and restaurants that double as music venues, such as Culinary Dropout and The Rathskeller, creating a food culture where dining is part of a complete social night out.

What Type of Casual Restaurant is Commonly Found in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis's casual dining is marked by a large number of gastropubs and restaurants in historic buildings that often feature live entertainment. These different kinds of Indianapolis restaurants make up the city's well-known food offerings.

Gastropubs with Live Music: These are large, high-energy restaurants that serve chef-driven American food and host regular live music performances. Union 50 and Culinary Dropout are primary examples.
Historic and Themed Restaurants: This category includes dining rooms located in significant historic buildings. The Rathskeller (German Athenaeum), Livery (19th-century stable), and Conner's Kitchen + Bar (modern Midwestern) fit this description.
Modern Taquerias: These are trendy, bar-focused spots that serve creative, non-traditional tacos. Agave & Rye and Bakersfield are key examples.
Cuisine-Specific Eateries: These are restaurants dedicated to a particular type of food, often from a specific country or region. The Rathskeller (German) and Diavola (Neapolitan pizza) are prominent examples.
Large-Format Beer Bars: This includes massive restaurants known for an extensive draft beer selection. Yard House, with over 100 taps, is the main example.

Does Indianapolis Have an Authentic Casual Restaurant?

Yes, Indianapolis has casual restaurants that are genuine representations of specific culinary and architectural traditions. The Rathskeller is an authentic German restaurant and Biergarten that has operated for over 100 years in the city's historic Athenaeum, a German-American landmark building from the 1890s. Diavola is a genuine Neapolitan pizzeria, using a wood-fired oven imported from Naples and adhering to the traditional methods for making the pizza. Livery is housed in an actual 19th-century stable, preserving the building's historic brick and wood architecture as a core part of its identity.

Do Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis Offer Easy Online Reservations?

Yes, securing a table online is an option at many of Indianapolis's popular casual restaurants. Chef-driven spots like Union 50 and Livery, which are often busy, use platforms like OpenTable and Resy, and reservations are highly recommended. The Rathskeller also accepts online reservations for its indoor dining room. Large, high-traffic restaurants like Yard House and Culinary Dropout also take reservations. More casual taquerias like Bakersfield and Agave & Rye may have limited reservations or operate on a first-come, first-served basis.

What are the Signature Dishes of the Best Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis's best casual restaurants are identified by signature dishes that range from historic German fare to creative, modern tacos. The following list describes some of the most notable food in Indianapolis.

Wiener Schnitzel: A classic German dish of a thin, breaded, and pan-fried veal cutlet, served with lemon. This is a main specialty at The Rathskeller.
Pretzel Bites & Provolone Fondue: Warm, soft pretzel bites served with a creamy provolone cheese dip. This is the most famous appetizer at Culinary Dropout.
Empanadas: Baked or fried turnovers with savory fillings. The menu at Livery features several different kinds, including beef, chicken, and vegetarian options.
"Epic" Tacos: Over-the-top tacos served in a double-shell (crispy corn and soft flour) with unconventional fillings like truffle mac & cheese or hot chicken. This is the signature concept at Agave & Rye.
Neapolitan Pizza: Pizza made according to the strict traditions of Naples, with a thin, soft crust and a slightly charred edge from a wood-burning oven. This is the sole focus at Diavola.

What is the Average Meal Price at Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis?

A meal at a casual restaurant in Indianapolis costs between $20 and $70 per person. A single meal at a fast-casual spot like Rosemary and Olive is between $10 and $20. A group meal for two to four people at a sit-down restaurant such as Yard House or The Rathskeller is between $70 and $150. A meal at a budget-friendly spot like Rosemary and Olive costs $10 to $20 per person. A full dinner with drinks at an upscale-casual restaurant like Livery or Union 50 costs $50 to $80 per person.

Are There Vegan Options at Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis?

Yes, vegan options are available at casual restaurants in Indianapolis, such as Livery, Agave & Rye, and Rosemary and Olive. Livery's Latin-inspired menu includes several vegetable-based small plates that can be prepared vegan. Agave & Rye offers vegan fillings for its "epic" tacos. Rosemary and Olive's build-your-own Mediterranean bowl concept allows for numerous vegan combinations with falafel, grains, and vegetables.

Do Casual Restaurants in Indianapolis Offer Gluten-Free Options?

Yes, casual restaurants in Indianapolis offer many gluten-free options at places like Livery, Bakersfield, and Conner's Kitchen + Bar. Livery's menu of Latin small plates includes many naturally gluten-free items like grilled meats and paella. Bakersfield serves all of its tacos on corn tortillas. Conner's Kitchen + Bar has a menu with gluten-free dishes clearly marked, including its shrimp and grits.