10 Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn
The ten best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn are Lilia, Misi, I Cavallini, Piccola Cucina Casa, Frankies 457 Spuntino, Pasta Louise, Michael’s of Brooklyn, Randazzo’s Clam Bar, Antica Pesa Brooklyn, and Cafe Mars. The borough's Italian food culture is defined by its exceptional range, from world-renowned, chef-driven destinations to historic, multi-generational institutions. Fine dining is exemplified by the masterful and nationally acclaimed pasta of Lilia and its sister restaurant Misi, while classic neighborhood specialists such as Frankies 457 Spuntino provide a genuine taste of rustic Italian-American cooking.
Brooklyn neighborhoods like Williamsburg, Carroll Gardens, and Sheepshead Bay are hubs for Italian cuisine. The best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn showcase a spectrum of concepts, from minimalist, waterfront pasta bars and historic clam bars to family-owned trattorias. The settings include world-famous, high-demand spaces, beloved backyard gardens, and casual neighborhood pasta shops.
Brooklyn’s Italian establishments are recognized for their culinary excellence and deep neighborhood roots. Lilia stands out as the number 1 Italian restaurant in the borough, celebrated for its James Beard Award-winning chef, perfectly executed handmade pastas, and status as a national dining destination. Frankies 457 Spuntino is a local favorite for classic and casual meals, known for its rustic dishes and famous garden patio. The distinction for another world-class, pasta-focused experience among the Italian restaurants in Brooklyn NY goes to Misi, which offers a menu dedicated solely to handmade pastas and vegetable antipasti.
10 Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn are listed below.
-
1
Frankies 457 SpuntinoFrankies 457 Spuntino is a beloved Italian-American restaurant in Carroll Gardens known for its menu of small plates ('spuntino'), house-made pastas, and sandwiches. The establishment offers a casual, rustic dining experience with a popular garden patio.- Item Prices 55
- Average Item Price $17.47
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian-American
Signature Dishes:Cavatelli with Faicco's Hot Sausage & Browned Sage ButterMeatballsEggplant Marinara Sandwich
Location:457 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Special Feature:The restaurant features a large, charming, and secluded garden in the back, providing a tranquil al fresco dining space.
What Makes It Special:Frankies is a neighborhood institution, celebrated for its consistently delicious, simple Italian-American food and its relaxed, convivial atmosphere.
What Sets It Apart:Its beautiful and highly sought-after garden patio, combined with its long-standing reputation as a foundational restaurant in the Brooklyn dining scene, gives Frankies a unique and respected status.
Operating Hours:Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Price:$30 to $50 per person
-
2
Pasta LouisePasta Louise is a casual, community-focused Italian restaurant and fresh pasta shop in Park Slope. The establishment operates as an all-day cafe and a dinner spot, serving handmade pasta, sandwiches, and pastries in a bright, family-friendly setting.- Item Prices 155
- Average Item Price $11.03
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian, Pasta Shop
Signature Dishes:Spicy RigatoniCacio e PepeMeatballs
Location:803 8th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Special Feature:The restaurant functions as a hybrid model, selling its fresh, handmade pasta and sauces for customers to cook at home, in addition to its dine-in service.
What Makes It Special:Pasta Louise is known for its accessible, high-quality fresh pasta and its strong community engagement, including offering free kids' meals.
What Sets It Apart:Its dual function as a neighborhood restaurant and a retail pasta shop, combined with its explicit community-first ethos, creates a unique and welcoming business model.
Operating Hours:Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 9:00 PMSaturday – Sunday: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Price:$20 to $30 per person
-
3
Randazzo's Clam BarRandazzo’s Clam Bar is a historic Italian-American seafood restaurant in Sheepshead Bay. A neighborhood fixture for generations, it is famous for its raw bar, fried seafood, and signature spicy marinara sauce.- Item Prices 92
- Average Item Price $17.15
Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian-American Seafood
Signature Dishes:Spaghetti with Red Clam SauceFried CalamariRaw Clams and Oysters
Location:2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235
Special Feature:The restaurant is known for its two styles of marinara sauce, medium and hot, which are a key component of many dishes and have become a local legend.
What Makes It Special:Randazzo's is a classic Brooklyn institution, celebrated for its no-frills, fresh seafood and its timeless, waterfront clam bar atmosphere.
What Sets It Apart:Its specific focus on Italian-American seafood preparations, particularly its raw bar and famous sauces, distinguishes Randazzo's from pasta- and meat-centric Italian restaurants.
Operating Hours:Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Price:$30 to $60 per person
-
4
LiliaLilia is a highly acclaimed Italian restaurant in Williamsburg from Chef Missy Robbins. The menu focuses on wood-fired seafood, grilled meats, and, most notably, exquisite, handmade pastas served in a bright, airy, and renovated former auto body shop.Type of Restaurant:Fine Dining
Type of Food:Modern Italian
Signature Dishes:Sheep's Milk Cheese Filled AgnolottiMafaldini with Pink PeppercornsGrilled Clams with Calabrian Chili
Location:567 Union Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Special Feature:The restaurant's design features high ceilings, large windows, and an open kitchen, creating a sophisticated yet comfortable atmosphere that is one of the most sought-after reservations in New York City.
What Makes It Special:Lilia is celebrated for its masterful and perfectly executed fresh pastas, which have earned the restaurant national recognition and a James Beard Award for its chef.
What Sets It Apart:The combination of a star chef's precise and innovative approach to pasta with a stunning, high-demand setting makes Lilia a benchmark for modern Italian dining.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday: 4:00 PM – 9:30 PMFriday – Sunday: 5:00 PM – 9:30 PM
Price:$50 to $100 per person
-
5
MisiMisi is the second Williamsburg restaurant from Chef Missy Robbins, located on the waterfront with views of the Manhattan skyline. The menu focuses exclusively on ten handmade pasta dishes and a variety of vegetable antipasti.Type of Restaurant:Fine Dining
Type of Food:Modern Italian (Pasta-focused)
Signature Dishes:Sheep's Milk Ricotta Filled OcchiSpinach and Mascarpone Filled TortelliSlow Roasted Tomatoes
Location:329 Kent Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Special Feature:The menu is strictly composed of vegetable antipasti and pasta dishes, with no traditional meat or fish main courses, in a modern space with a large, open kitchen.
What Makes It Special:Misi distills the most acclaimed element of its sister restaurant, Lilia—the pasta—into a focused, dedicated menu, served in a beautiful setting with dramatic city views.
What Sets It Apart:Its unique menu structure that eliminates traditional main courses in favor of perfecting pasta and vegetables makes Misi a singular and highly sought-after dining experience.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday: 5:00 PM – 9:30 PMFriday – Sunday: 4:30 PM – 9:30 PM
Price:$50 to $100 per person
-
6
I CavalliniI Cavallini is a family-owned Italian restaurant in the Clinton Hill neighborhood, serving classic, traditional dishes in a cozy and intimate setting. The menu features homestyle recipes from various regions of Italy.Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian
Signature Dishes:Tagliatelle alla BologneseCostoletta di Vitello (Veal Chop)Pollo Scarpariello
 .jpg.jpg)
Location:284 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Special Feature:The restaurant maintains a warm, neighborhood-gem atmosphere, with personal service often provided by the owners themselves.
What Makes It Special:I Cavallini is a beloved local fixture, celebrated for its consistent, high-quality execution of traditional Italian food in a welcoming, unpretentious environment.
What Sets It Apart:Its long-standing reputation as a reliable, owner-operated establishment for authentic, classic Italian cuisine gives I Cavallini a distinct and respected status in its neighborhood.
Operating Hours:Wednesday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PMSunday – Tuesday: Closed
Price:Over $100 per person
-
7
Piccola Cucina CasaPiccola Cucina Casa is a Sicilian restaurant in a historic brownstone in Boerum Hill, part of the acclaimed Piccola Cucina group. The establishment focuses on authentic Sicilian cuisine, particularly fresh seafood and handmade pastas, in a lively, communal atmosphere.Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Sicilian Italian
Signature Dishes:Maccheroni alla NormaAranciniBranzino al Sale
Location:141 Nevins Street Brooklyn, New York, New York 11217
Special Feature:The restaurant is designed to feel like a traditional Sicilian home ('casa'), with a warm, rustic interior and an emphasis on shared dining experiences.
What Makes It Special:Piccola Cucina Casa is known for its faithful representation of Sicilian food, its high-energy environment, and its dedication to fresh, high-quality ingredients.
What Sets It Apart:Its specific focus on the culinary traditions of Sicily, combined with the group's reputation for excellent pasta, provides a distinct and transportive dining experience.
Operating Hours:Monday – Friday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PMSaturday – Sunday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Price:$50 to $100 per person
-
8
Michael’s of BrooklynMichael's of Brooklyn is a long-standing, family-owned Italian-American restaurant and food purveyor in the Marine Park neighborhood. Operating since 1964, it serves classic, traditional dishes and sells its own line of house-made sauces.Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Italian-American
Signature Dishes:Veal ParmesanLobster Fra DiavoloSpaghetti with Marinara Sauce
Location:2929 Avenue R, Brooklyn, NY 11229
Special Feature:The restaurant has a retail operation, selling its famous, jarred marinara sauce and other Italian specialty products in the restaurant and in stores nationwide.
What Makes It Special:Michael's is a Brooklyn institution, celebrated for its six decades of serving consistent, old-school Italian-American food to generations of families.
What Sets It Apart:Its extensive history and its successful transition into a national food brand with its jarred sauces give Michael's a unique status as both a neighborhood restaurant and a culinary landmark.
Operating Hours:Tuesday – Sunday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PMMonday: Closed
Price:$50 to $100 per person
-
9
Antica Pesa BrooklynAntica Pesa Brooklyn is the Williamsburg outpost of a historic restaurant in Rome. The establishment offers authentic, contemporary Roman cuisine in a sophisticated, industrial-chic setting.Type of Restaurant:Fine Dining
Type of Food:Roman Italian
Signature Dishes:Cacio e PepeSpaghetto alla CarbonaraAmatriciana
Location:115 Berry St, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Special Feature:The restaurant is run by the fourth generation of the same family that has operated the original Antica Pesa in Rome since 1922, bringing a direct family lineage to the Brooklyn location.
What Makes It Special:Antica Pesa is known for its faithful yet modern interpretation of classic Roman dishes, served in a stylish environment that attracts an international clientele.
What Sets It Apart:Its direct connection to a historic Roman restaurant and its specific focus on the authentic cuisine of Rome give Antica Pesa a unique and pedigreed identity.
Operating Hours:Monday – Thursday, Sunday: 6:00 PM – 10:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 6:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Price:$50 to $100 per person
-
10
Cafe MarsCafe Mars is a contemporary, inventive Italian-inspired restaurant in the Gowanus neighborhood. The menu features a creative and unconventional take on Italian-American cuisine, blending traditional flavors with unique, unexpected ingredients.Type of Restaurant:Casual Dining
Type of Food:Modern Italian-American
Signature Dishes:Jellyfish CarbonaraTuna ParmGnocchi Fritto
Location:272 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Special Feature:The restaurant's design is retro-futuristic, with a unique, space-age-meets-Italian-diner aesthetic that complements its quirky menu.
What Makes It Special:Cafe Mars is known for its playful and experimental approach to Italian food, deconstructing classic dishes and reassembling them in surprising new ways.
What Sets It Apart:Its self-described "weirdo Italian" or "Italo-surrealist" culinary philosophy is its defining feature, making Cafe Mars a distinct destination for adventurous diners.
Operating Hours:Wednesday – Saturday: 5:30 PM – 9:00 PMSunday: 5:30 PM – 8:00 PMMonday – Tuesday: Closed
Price:$50 to $100 per person
What Makes Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn Famous?
Italian restaurants in Brooklyn are famous for their remarkable diversity, ranging from world-renowned, chef-driven destinations in Williamsburg to historic, multi-generational red-sauce institutions in the southern neighborhoods. The borough's reputation is built on both culinary innovation and deep-rooted tradition. It is home to nationally acclaimed restaurants like Lilia, where Chef Missy Robbins has redefined modern pasta, and also to century-old establishments like Randazzo's Clam Bar in Sheepshead Bay. This ability to support both cutting-edge cuisine and classic, neighborhood-defining restaurants sets Brooklyn apart. The best Italian food in Brooklyn is characterized by this spectrum, from the simple, perfect cavatelli at Frankies 457 Spuntino to the inventive dishes at Cafe Mars.
What Type of Italian Restaurant is Commonly Found in Brooklyn?
Brooklyn features a dynamic mix of Italian restaurant types, reflecting the borough's diverse neighborhoods and its status as a global culinary destination. The borough's Italian dining options are grouped into several main categories:
- Modern Chef-Driven Restaurants: These are critically acclaimed establishments, often in trendy neighborhoods like Williamsburg and Gowanus, led by renowned chefs who focus on innovative, seasonal menus and house-made pasta. Lilia, Barbuto Brooklyn, and Cafe Mars are prime examples.
- Classic Italian-American Restaurants: These are historic, often family-owned spots in neighborhoods like Carroll Gardens, Marine Park, and Sheepshead Bay, serving generous portions of traditional comfort food. Frankies 457 Spuntino, Michael’s of Brooklyn, and Randazzo's Clam Bar represent this style.
- Regional Italian Specialists: These restaurants concentrate on the specific cuisine of a single Italian region, offering an authentic and focused culinary experience. Piccola Cucina Casa (Sicilian) and Antica Pesa Brooklyn (Roman) fit this category.
- Neighborhood Pasta Shops: These are casual, often counter-service establishments that function as both a retail shop for fresh pasta and a restaurant. Pasta Louise is a well-known model for this style.
Does Brooklyn Have an Authentic Italian Restaurant?
Yes, Brooklyn has many authentic Italian restaurants, with Antica Pesa Brooklyn and Piccola Cucina Casa being prominent examples. Antica Pesa demonstrates authenticity through its direct lineage to a historic restaurant in Rome, run by the same family since 1922, and its menu is dedicated to classic Roman dishes like Cacio e Pepe and Carbonara. Piccola Cucina Casa is devoted to the authentic cuisine of Sicily, serving traditional dishes like Maccheroni alla Norma and Arancini in a setting designed to feel like a Sicilian home.
What are the Signature Dishes of the Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn?
The best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn are known for signature dishes like the Sheep's Milk Agnolotti at Lilia, the JW Chicken at Barbuto, and the Cavatelli with Hot Sausage at Frankies 457 Spuntino. The most notable signature dishes are listed below.
- Sheep's Milk Cheese Filled Agnolotti: A signature dish from Lilia, these delicate, handmade pasta parcels are served in a saffron, dried tomato, and honey sauce, showcasing Chef Missy Robbins' masterful approach to pasta.
- JW Chicken: The legendary dish from Chef Jonathan Waxman at Barbuto, this is a perfectly roasted half chicken served with a vibrant salsa verde, celebrated for its simplicity and flawless execution.
- Cavatelli with Faicco's Hot Sausage & Browned Sage Butter: The quintessential dish from Frankies 457 Spuntino, this simple, rustic pasta has been a neighborhood favorite for years and represents the restaurant's comforting, high-quality cooking.
- Spaghetti with Red Clam Sauce: A classic Italian-American seafood dish that is a staple at the historic Randazzo’s Clam Bar, famous for its signature spicy marinara sauce.
- Cacio e Pepe: The classic Roman pasta dish is a benchmark for authenticity at Antica Pesa Brooklyn, prepared according to traditional methods passed down through the family's Roman restaurant.
Does Brooklyn Enjoy Italian Food?
Yes, Brooklyn enjoys Italian food. The borough's deep Italian-American roots are evident in historic neighborhoods like Carroll Gardens and Bensonhurst, and this heritage is maintained by iconic, multi-generational restaurants such as Michael's of Brooklyn and Randazzo's Clam Bar. The immense popularity and critical acclaim of modern, destination restaurants like Lilia and Barbuto Brooklyn demonstrate that Italian cuisine is not just a part of the borough's history, but a central and evolving component of its world-class dining scene.
Are There Vegan Options in Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn?
Yes, Italian restaurants in Brooklyn have vegan options, with establishments like Lilia, Barbuto Brooklyn, and Pasta Louise accommodating plant-based diets. As chef-driven restaurants, Lilia and Barbuto are accustomed to handling dietary requests and can create custom vegan dishes based on their seasonal, vegetable-forward menus. Casual spots like Pasta Louise offer pasta with marinara sauce and have several vegetable-based sides, providing straightforward vegan choices.
Do Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn Offer Gluten-Free Options?
Yes, Italian restaurants in Brooklyn offer gluten-free options, including Lilia, Frankies 457 Spuntino, and Antica Pesa Brooklyn. High-end, modern restaurants like Lilia provide gluten-free pasta substitutes for their acclaimed dishes. Neighborhood staples like Frankies 457 Spuntino can also accommodate gluten-free requests. Restaurants with a focus on grilled items, such as Barbuto Brooklyn, feature numerous naturally gluten-free entrees like grilled fish and steak.
What is the Average Meal Price for Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn?
The cost of an Italian meal in Brooklyn ranges from $20 to over $200 per person. A meal at a casual pasta shop like Pasta Louise is priced between $20 and $40. The price per person at mid-range, classic restaurants like Frankies 457 Spuntino or Michael's of Brooklyn is from $30 to $60. Upscale restaurants such as Barbuto or Antica Pesa have prices that begin at $50 and can exceed $100, while a meal at a premier destination like Lilia costs over $200 per person.
Find your next favorite spot
Can't decide? start here: