10 Best Italian Restaurants in Providence Federal Hill

The ten best Italian restaurants in Providence Federal Hill include Al Forno, Pizzico, Siena, Caffe Dolce Vita, Massimo Restaurant, Federal Hill Pizza, Andino's, Cucina Rustica, Trattoria Romana, and The Old Canteen. Situated along the historic Atwells Avenue corridor, these Italian dining spots define Rhode Island's most famous neighborhood for Mediterranean-inspired meals. Diners discover menu options such as grilled pizzas, calamari tossed with hot peppers, and handmade pasta served in slow-cooked sauces. The chefs in these top restaurants earn recognition for executing regional specialties like veal chop Milanese, stuffed chicken parmigiana, and fresh seafood harvested from Narragansett Bay. 

Many Italian restaurants in Providence Federal Hill  occupy multi-story brick buildings featuring ornate facades and sidewalk seating that stretches along the avenue. An individual meal at an Italian restaurant in Providence Federal Hill averages $45.

Al Forno secures a top position for its innovative approach to grilled dough, while Siena provides a premier spot for rustic, ingredient-focused cooking. Andino's serves as a dependable choice for large, family-style portions in a neighborhood-focused setting.

The top best Italian restaurants in Providence Federal Hill are listed below.

  1. AL FORNO 1
    AL FORNO 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 145
    • Average Item Price $11.50
    Type of Restaurant:

    Fine Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian

    Signature Dishes:

    Grilled Pizza Margherita
    Dirty Steak
    Baked Pasta

    AL FORNO signature dishes Grilled Pizza Margherita
Dirty Steak
Baked Pasta
    Location:

    577 S Water St, Providence, RI 02903, United States

    Special Feature:

    The open-fire grill is the centerpiece of the cooking process.

    What Makes It Special:

    A revolutionary approach to pizza and pasta that has influenced chefs nationwide.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The commitment to open-fire cooking and seasonal ingredients creates a unique dining experience.

    Operating Hours:

    Monday: ClosedTuesday – Friday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PMSaturday: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PMSunday: Closed

    Price:

    $50 to $100 per person

    AL FORNO Menu Prices
  2. Pizzico 2
    Pizzico 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 544
    • Average Item Price $13.64
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian

    Signature Dishes:

    Lobster Penne Alla Vodka
    Fried Oysters
    Veal Saltimbocca De Vitello

    Pizzico signature dishes Lobster Penne Alla Vodka
Fried Oysters
Veal Saltimbocca De Vitello
    Location:

    762 Hope St Providence, RI 02906

    Special Feature:

    The menu features a selection of daily fish specials sourced from local waters.

    What Makes It Special:

    A consistent delivery of flavorful, well-prepared meals in a comfortable setting.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The focus on fresh ingredients and friendly service makes it a neighborhood favorite.

    Operating Hours:

    Monday – Thursday: 4:00 PM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PMSunday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM

    Price:

    $30 to $50 per person

    Pizzico Menu Prices
  3. Siena 3
    Siena 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 298
    • Average Item Price $16.45
    Type of Restaurant:

    Fine Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian, Tuscan

    Signature Dishes:

    Calamari Fritti
    Margherita
    Rigatoni del Calzolaio

    Siena signature dishes Calamari Fritti
Margherita
Rigatoni del Calzolaio
    Location:

    238 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02903, United States

    Special Feature:

    The dining room features a large stone fireplace, adding to the rustic ambiance.

    What Makes It Special:

    A dedication to the rustic, hearty flavors of Tuscany.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The upscale atmosphere and focus on traditional wood-fired cooking define the experience.

    Operating Hours:

    Permanently Closed

    Price:

    $40 to $50 per person

    Siena Menu Prices
  4. Caffe Dolce Vita 4
    Caffe Dolce Vita 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 33
    • Average Item Price $30.72
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian

    Signature Dishes:

    Chicken Parmigiana
    Spaghetti Al Pomodoro Con Polpette
    Bailey's Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

    Caffe Dolce Vita signature dishes Chicken Parmigiana
Spaghetti Al Pomodoro Con Polpette
Bailey's Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
    Location:

    59 De Pasquale Ave, Providence, RI 02903, United States

    Special Feature:

    The outdoor patio provides prime seating for observing the neighborhood activity.

    What Makes It Special:

    A casual, unpretentious vibe that encourages long conversations over coffee and food.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The focus on simple, high-quality ingredients and a relaxed pace sets it apart.

    Operating Hours:

    Permanently Closed

    Price:

    $20 to $30 per person

    Caffe Dolce Vita Menu Prices
  5. Federal Hill Pizza 5
    Federal Hill Pizza 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 170
    • Average Item Price $15.90
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian, Pizza

    Signature Dishes:

    Classic Margherita Pizza
    Chicken Wings
    12" Owner's Favorite

    Federal Hill Pizza signature dishes Classic Margherita Pizza
Chicken Wings
12" Owner's Favorite
    Location:

    1039 Chalkstone Ave Providence, RI 02908

    Special Feature:

    The dough undergoes a 48-hour fermentation process for maximum flavor.

    What Makes It Special:

    A focus on the craft of pizza-making using traditional methods.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The dedication to artisanal dough and fresh toppings makes it a local favorite.

    Operating Hours:

    Closed

    Price:

    $20 to $30 per person

    Federal Hill Pizza Menu Prices
  6. Andino's 6
    Andino's 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 32
    • Average Item Price $15.05
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian-American

    Signature Dishes:

    Stuffed Chicken Parmigiana
    Italian Grinder Sandwich
    Fettuccine Alfredo

    Andino's signature dishes Stuffed Chicken Parmigiana
Italian Grinder Sandwich
Fettuccine Alfredo
    Location:

    171 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02903

    Special Feature:

    The menu includes a large selection of sandwiches and pasta combinations.

    What Makes It Special:

    A welcoming, unpretentious atmosphere that feels like a neighborhood gathering spot.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The focus on simple, satisfying, and consistent recipes defines the experience.

    Operating Hours:

    Monday - Thursday: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PMFriday - Saturday: 11:30 AM - 11:00 PMSunday: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM

    Price:

    $30 to $50 per person

    Andino's Menu Prices
  7. Cucina Rustica 7
    Cucina Rustica 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 35
    • Average Item Price $17.56
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian

    Signature Dishes:

    Marinara and Meatball Pasta
    Clams Casino Pizza
    Ribeye

    Cucina Rustica signature dishes Marinara and Meatball Pasta
Clams Casino Pizza
Ribeye
    Location:

    555 Atwood Ave, Cranston, RI 02920

    Special Feature:

    The dining room utilizes reclaimed wood and stone to create a rustic environment.

    What Makes It Special:

    A dedication to the slow-food movement and locally sourced produce.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The focus on earthy, countryside flavors provides a unique alternative to standard menus.

    Operating Hours:

    Monday – Tuesday: ClosedWednesday – Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PMSunday: 11:30 AM – 8:00 PM

    Price:

    $20 to $30 per person

    Cucina Rustica Menu Prices
  8. Trattoria Romana 8
    Trattoria Romana 0.00 (0 Reviews)
    • Item Prices 206
    • Average Item Price $19.40
    Type of Restaurant:

    Fine Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian

    Signature Dishes:

    Stuffed Mushrooms
    Chicken Marsala
    Stuffed Pork Chop

    Trattoria Romana signature dishes Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Marsala
Stuffed Pork Chop
    Location:

    3 Wake Robin Rd Ste 1 Lincoln, RI 02865

    Special Feature:

    The staff provides tableside service for various appetizers and desserts.

    What Makes It Special:

    A commitment to formal service standards and classic Italian recipes.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The combination of traditional service and high-end ingredients defines the experience.

    Operating Hours:

    Monday: ClosedTuesday – Thursday: 4:30 PM – 9:00 PMFriday – Saturday: 4:30 PM – 10:00 PMSunday: 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM

    Price:

    $50 to $100 per person

    Trattoria Romana Menu Prices
  9. Massimo Restaurant 9
    Massimo Restaurant
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian

    Signature Dishes:

    Fettucine Bolognese
    Ziti Rigati del Cardinale
    Chicken Parmigiano

    Massimo Restaurant signature dishes Fettucine Bolognese
Ziti Rigati del Cardinale
Chicken Parmigiano
    Location:

    134 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02903

    Special Feature:

    The dining room offers a view of the bustling street, perfect for people-watching.

    What Makes It Special:

    A focus on consistent, high-quality preparation of classic Italian staples.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The combination of a central location and a reliable menu defines the experience.

    Operating Hours:

    Monday - Thursday: 11:30 AM - 9:30 PMFriday - Saturday: 11:30 AM - 10:30 PMSunday: 10:30 AM - 9:30 PM

    Price:

    $30 to $50 per person

  10. The Old Canteen 10
    The Old Canteen
    Type of Restaurant:

    Casual Dining

    Type of Food:

    Italian-American

    Signature Dishes:

    Shrimp Scampi
    Chicken Marsala
    Spaghetti with Meat Sauce

    The Old Canteen signature dishes Shrimp Scampi
Chicken Marsala
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
    Location:

    120 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI 02903

    Special Feature:

    The interior remains largely unchanged, preserving the mid-century aesthetic.

    What Makes It Special:

    A time-capsule experience that honors the history of the neighborhood.

    What Sets It Apart:

    The preservation of the original menu and decor makes it a unique destination.

    Operating Hours:

    Permanently closed

    Price:

    $30 to $50 per person